Welcome to Michael’s Blog!

Welcome to Michael's blog. Michael Andrew, (aka Michael The Maven) is a freelance producer, photography instructor, tech innovator, and when needed, disaster aid specialist. Disclaimer: Michael is a participant in Bhphoto & Amazon affiliate programs that provides an advertising commission if you purchase through links on this website.


Viewing one post  |  view all recent posts

03.19.19         michael's insights  

Has National Geographic Exploited the Unprotected? My Thoughts on the Afghan Girl Controversy




No one has asked me to make this video.

This video is not sponsored, nor is monetized.

I am making it because it is something I feel passionate about & all things expressed here are my own opinions. I feel tremendous empathy for children who suffer.

I am adding links to the resources to many of the points I have made, but these are not comprehensive, do your own research with an open mind and heart and come to your own conclusions. You are welcome to disagree and I can respect your opinions. If you feel passionate about it, make a video and publish it, even if you disagree!

TL/DW : Do not mess with children!

Especially if they do not have the protections we do! Even more so when they are marginalized, orphans, refugees or otherwise!

For over 100 years National Geographic has been the go to source for stories and images about the cultures of our world. We likely agree it has been spectacular in regards to providing the best images and stories to offer in this regard, and in the vast majority of cases, there are no issues. In the mid-80's it's circulation was about 12 million, and one of the biggest stages at the time for images.

Steve McCurry, one of the most famous and talented photojournalists of our time, took the portrait of "Afghan Girl", most of us have seen.

There's just one problem... she didn't want her picture taken and attempted to cover her face. Through a translator, McCurry asked her teacher to tell her to do so for the sake of the greater good, bringing awareness to their situation. She has gone on record saying she was angry at the time. A few posed shots were taken some with and at least one without the face covering, after which she ran off.

McCurry has stated he knew it was a special portrait, yet he didn't get her name. That image went through a team of editors who decided to put it on the cover.

The question I have....if they didn't have a name, how could they have legal permission? How could the image go through at least 3 different people, if they didn't? How many other times has this happened?

If no legal permission was given, was this young woman's right to privacy violated?

As a society, we need to get away from "poverty porn", or commercializing those in compromised living conditions or those suffering, especially if they do not want their image used on a big stage.

Tony's Videos:
1- https://youtu.be/RuFKpaV_jjo
2- https://youtu.be/1q_NAEaiC9M

Sources I quote in this video:

The Washington Post Chat Interview with McCurry: (Many important questions are answered here, including if he had permission or paid her):https://wapo.st/2HGYL6f

BBC Interview & Sharbat Gula's mixed feelings, how there were more negatives than good, yet she was also proud of it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cfY2zfv7_V0

Steve Speaks about Afghan Culture in regards to photographing females: https://youtu.be/Mal2e4TBpPQ?t=268

Petal Pixel's McCurry Photoshop Scandal:

https://petapixel.com/2016/05/06/botched-steve-mccurry-print-leads-photoshop-scandal/

https://petapixel.com/2016/06/07/eyes-afghan-girl-critical-take-steve-mccurry-scandal/

Steve Responds:https://bit.ly/2TOKoEo

Time Article About Steve No Longer Being a Photojournalist, & Editor Sarah Been going on record about being proud of the image, yet the importance of the distinction between Photojournalism vs Other genres: http://time.com/4351725/steve-mccurry-not-photojournalist/

Steve States He Got Permission, but that both parents were dead: https://bit.ly/2YaGNyL

Steve Talks about the importance of permission & respecting privacy: https://youtu.be/iZktvSKW3Mw?t=441

Bob Gilka Had The Final Say: https://wapo.st/2HucEpl

Auction Prices For McCurry's Work: https://bit.ly/2HG5KfT

Nat Geo Sells Auctions Image for $147,000: https://wapo.st/2HJlfn5

Nat Geo Admits to Racism: https://on.natgeo.com/2tCCJwd

Steve Speaks Out About her arrest & violation of human rights: https://bit.ly/2FjEwbV

FAIR USE STATEMENT
This video may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. This material is being made available within this transformative or derivative work for the purpose of education, commentary and criticism is being distributed without profit and is believed to be “fair use” in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107.

blog stats
posts: 4,687
comments: 12,192
visits:
archive by month
2019:   january  february  march  april
2018:   january  february  march  april  may  june  july  august  september  october  november  december
2017:   january  february  march  april  may  june  july  august  september  october  november  december
2016:   january  february  march  april  may  june  july  august  september  october  november  december
2015:   january  february  march  april  may  june  july  august  september  october  november  december
2014:   january  february  march  april  may  june  july  august  september  october  november  december
2013:   january  february  march  april  may  june  july  august  september  october  november  december
2012:   january  february  march  april  may  june  july  august  september  october  november  december
2011:   january  february  march  april  may  june  july  august  september  october  november  december
2010:   january  february  march  april  may  june  july  august  september  october  november  december
2009:   january  february  march  april  may  june  july  august  september  october  november  december
2008:   january  february  march  april  may  june  july  august  september  october  november  december
2007:   january  july  august  september  october  november  december
Nikon D7100 Crash Course Training Tutorial VideoCanon 6D Crash Course Tutorial Training VideoMA- Maui Screen Savers 2009Digital Photography Crash Course DVDAdvanced Photography Techniques Lessons DVDBusiness Crash Course For PhotographersPhotoshop Crash Course DVD Beginner LessonsBH PhotoNikon D5300 Crash Course DownloadMichael Andrew Lollipops | Photoshop Action SetPaintballer ProCanon 600EX-RT Speedlite Crash CourseCanon Speedlite Crash Course DVDCanon 5Diii Crash Course Training VideoMichael Andrew Maui Desktop WallpaperPhotography Lighting Crash CourseMaven Adapter - Sky Cam Connector